Devraj Sanyal Says ‘Hit-Making’ Can No Longer Be Engineered In 2026 Music Economy

In a candid reflection on the evolving dynamics of the music industry, Devraj Sanyal has asserted that the long-standing belief in a “formula” for creating hit songs no longer holds true in 2026. According to him, the power has decisively shifted from labels and marketing machinery to fans, who now determine what succeeds and how.

For years, the industry operated on the assumption that hits could be engineered through large budgets, aggressive campaigns, and strategic rollouts. However, Sanyal argues that this approach has become obsolete. “No matter how much you spend or how well you plan, you don’t control what becomes a hit,” he noted, emphasizing that audiences today are guided by entirely different consumption patterns.

At the core of any successful track, he maintained, is still the song itself. While marketing, packaging, and distribution can amplify reach, they cannot compensate for weak content. “A good song is a good song,” he underscored, adding that this fundamental principle remains unchanged even as the ecosystem around it has transformed.

One of the most significant shifts, he explained, lies in distribution. No longer a backend function, distribution now plays a central role in determining a song’s visibility and success. It is no longer just about being available on platforms, but about appearing in the right contexts, at the right time, and within the right cultural ecosystems. Without this alignment, music risks becoming invisible.

Equally critical and often misunderstood, is the concept of hype. Sanyal pointed out that the industry’s conventional promotional cycles, including teasers and countdowns, are often mistaken for genuine anticipation. In reality, meaningful hype is built gradually through curiosity and engagement, allowing audiences to feel invested even before a release drops.

He also cautioned against the tendency to over-invest at the launch stage. Heavy advertising and immediate saturation may create short-term visibility, but can undermine long-term traction by making a song feel imposed rather than discovered. “People don’t fall in love with what they are told to like,” he observed, highlighting the importance of organic discovery.

In this context, short-form content and “sampling” have emerged as crucial drivers of success. Hooks, loops, and fragments circulating across reels and user-generated content now act as primary touchpoints, often preceding full-track engagement. However, he stressed the need for balance, overexposure can quickly lead to audience fatigue.

Central to this new paradigm is the role of fans. Far from being passive consumers, they now function as the primary drivers of distribution, amplification, and validation. Sanyal emphasized that fostering a sense of ownership among fans—through early access, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes engagement,can transform them into active advocates.

Another notable shift is the industry’s changing relationship with time. While earlier metrics focused on immediate impact, today’s hits often build gradually, finding different audiences over time. Patience, therefore, has become a strategic necessity rather than a luxury.

He further noted that gimmicks and manufactured virality are increasingly ineffective, as audiences are quick to identify and reject inauthentic trends. Instead, platforms now reward consistent participation, engagement, and authenticity over traditional markers of stardom.

Addressing the role of algorithms, Sanyal remarked that they cannot be manipulated but must be understood and respected. Driven by real user behavior and engagement, algorithms amplify content that resonates organically, reinforcing the central role of audience choice.

Ultimately, he concluded, the definition of a hit has fundamentally changed. “You don’t decide the hit. The audience does,” he stated, adding that when a song is embraced by listeners, it transcends ownership and becomes part of culture.

In an era where control has shifted decisively toward listeners, the industry’s challenge is no longer to manufacture success,but to earn it.

Read Full Article on: https://substack.com/home/post/p-193658495