Javed Akhtar Flags Growing Interference In Film Music, Urges Creative Freedom

At the launch of the IPRS-EY Music Creator Report, the veteran lyricist also raised concerns over creators’ earnings and the implementation of copyright laws

Javed Akhtar Flags Growing Interference In Film Music, Urges Creative Freedom

Veteran lyricist and screenwriter Javed Akhtar has raised concerns over the growing interference of film producers and music companies in the creative process, saying composers and lyricists are often not given enough freedom to create music according to their artistic vision.

Speaking at the launch of the Indian Performing Right Society’s (IPRS) EY Music Creator Report, Akhtar said producers should trust the music directors they appoint and allow them the creative freedom to develop a musical style that complements the film.

“If you don’t trust a music director, then don’t take him. If you trust him and he has talent, then give him a chance to do the music the way he wants to,” Akhtar said, citing the work of legendary composer S.D. Burman in films such as Chalti Ka Naam Gaadi and Sujata.

Drawing a comparison with filmmaking, he said involving multiple directors to shoot different scenes would affect a film’s overall coherence.

Akhtar also criticised the conditions imposed by producers and music companies on composers and lyricists, arguing that such interference often limits the quality of creative output.

“Somewhere we’ve moved away from the purpose. The problem is the tail is wagging the dog, that should not happen. There’s too much interference, conditions. When a writer writes lyrics, they can do 100 times better work but they are not allowed to do so,” he said.

Recalling an instance of creative interference, Akhtar said a music company executive had once objected to his use of the word ‘roothana’ in a song, arguing that it would not appeal to audiences. Akhtar countered by citing several successful songs that had used the same word.

He added that people often assume they understand music and songwriting, even when they lack the expertise to make creative decisions.

Javed Akhtar questions creators’ share in music industry revenue

Akhtar also questioned how much of the music industry's revenue reaches the people who create it, including music directors, singers and lyricists.

According to the IPRS-EY report, India's music creator economy generated an estimated ₹17,400 crore in 2025, registering 45% growth since 2023. Revenue from sound recording and music publishing stood at ₹5,433 crore during the year, while the number of original songs released annually rose to between 22,000 and 27,000.

However, Akhtar expressed concern over the distribution of these earnings, saying creators receive a disproportionately small share of the industry's revenue.

“The rest of them are selling it, they are brokers and commission agents. Out of Rs. 5,000 crore, how much do the creators get? Not even Rs. 1,000 crore, so something is seriously wrong with the system,” he said.

Calls for stronger copyright enforcement amid AI growth

The lyricist also called for stronger implementation of copyright laws to protect creators as technology, particularly artificial intelligence (AI), continues to reshape the music industry.

Referring to the use of iconic voices and recordings, Akhtar questioned whether the families of late artists such as Kishore Kumar receive adequate compensation when their music continues to be used and circulated.

He stressed the need for international laws to address emerging concerns around voice rights and AI, while also pointing to gaps in the enforcement of existing copyright provisions in India.

Akhtar claimed that only around 4% of hotels, restaurants, bars and event venues pay royalties, highlighting the need for stronger compliance across the industry.

His remarks brought renewed attention to two key challenges facing India's music ecosystem: protecting creative freedom and ensuring that music creators receive a fair share of the value generated by their work.